The Winters Doctrine: The Foundation of Tribal Water Rights

In the era of modern water law, tribes have buttressed their water rights by drawing on a 1908 Supreme Court opinion in a case involving the use of the Milk River in north central Montana. In that case, Winters v. US, the court found that when the federal government created the Fort Belknap reservation it implicitly reserved the rights to use a sufficient amount of the river’s water to fulfill the purposes of the reservation as a homeland for the Gros Ventre and Assiniboine people.

These “Winters doctrine” rights, now applied to tribes in Arizona and across the country, have a number of distinctive aspects to them.

●      The rights are considered as having been established as of the date the federal government created the reservation involved. This means that tribal rights are nearly always senior to those of most other current users of Western water.

●      The rights cannot be forfeited by non-use, as can the rights held under state law according to the principle of “prior appropriation.”

●      Although the scope of these rights is sometimes quantified as being the amount of water necessary to support the “practically irrigable acreage” on a reservation, the rights, once quantified, can be used for non-agricultural purposes.

●      The rights involve the future needs on a reservation, not just the present needs.

The “Winters doctrine” and the specifics derived from it in case law and in federal legislation form the basis of the water rights of the tribes in Arizona.

Click here for the US Supreme Court decision in the Winters case.


nmd runnner nmd runnner black nmd runnner white nmd runnner grey nmd runnner gs ultra boost ultra boost black ultra boost white ultra boost grey ultra boost gs ultra boost uncaged ultra boost uncaged black ultra boost uncaged white ultra boost uncaged grey ultra boost uncaged gs yeezy boost 350 yeezy boost 350 black yeezy boost 350 white yeezy boost 350 grey yeezy boost 350 gs yeezy boost 350 v2 yeezy boost 350 v2 black yeezy boost 350 v2 white yeezy boost 350 v2 grey yeezy boost 350 v2 gs yeezy boost 750 yeezy boost 750 black yeezy boost 750 white yeezy boost 750 grey yeezy boost 750 gs
jordan retro 7 gs jordan retro 7 black jordan retro 7 white jordan retro 7 grey jordan retro 7 gs jordan retro 7 jordan 7 retro black jordan 7 retro white jordan 7 retro grey jordan 7 retro gs jordan 12 retro jordan 12 retro black jordan 12 retro white jordan 12 retro grey jordan 12 retro gs jordan 12 retro gs jordan retro 12 black jordan retro 12 white jordan retro 12 grey jordan retro 12 gs